John Goehrke reached out to her by writing, "If Patriots win we go on a date?", and she responded "Sure".
The two met on Wednesday night and attended a Brooklyn Nets game in NY.
Afterwards, the couple was interviewed by TMZ while leaving Barclays Center, when the reporter asked how the date went, and, perhaps more importantly, if there will be a second date.
"There's a Nets game tonight, I think that would be a great date idea".
"Lesson learned. Never bet against Tom Brady".
The Atlanta Falcons were 21-3 up on the New England Patriots, a lead that would be extended by a further seven points in the third quarter. Bouchard said she was scared at first when she saw his profile was a picture of Tiger Woods.
The 22-year-old tennis star tweeted out on Wednesday "Just met my "Super Bowl Twitter Date" John". "I was a little bit anxious because his Twitter profile picture was a picture of Tiger Woods".
But during Sunday's Grammy awards, she joked that future random fans better not get their hopes up about repeating Goehrke's feat.
He turned out to be Goehrke, who is a massive LeBron James fan and has since switched his Twitter photo to one of him in a LeBron Cavs jersey.
'So this is a gift from my Twitter date John, ' she said. I didn't know what he looked like.
"But it turns out he seems to be a very nice boy". Unfortunately for Goerhrke, there is no indication as of yet that he managed to secure a second date.
Genie Bouchard lost a bet and a fan won bragging rights forever.